Which is cheaper, FHA or USDA?
When you qualify for USDA, it is usually cheaper: zero down, a 1% upfront fee, and a 0.35% annual fee versus FHA's 1.75% upfront and 0.55% annual MIP for most buyers. Qualifying is the catch.
Both are government-backed, low-cash ways to buy, and the choice usually makes itself: USDA offers zero down but only in eligible areas and only under an income limit, while FHA works anywhere with 3.5% down and no income cap. Here is the full comparison for Indiana buyers.
Down payment, geography, income, and insurance.
01
USDA is zero down. FHA is 3.5% down at a 580 credit score. If cash is the binding constraint and the home qualifies, USDA starts ahead.
02
USDA is limited to eligible rural and suburban areas. Much of Howard County outside Kokomo qualifies; FHA has no area restriction at all.
03
USDA caps household income at 115% of the area median, counting every adult in the home. FHA has no income limit.
04
USDA charges a 1% upfront guarantee fee and a 0.35% annual fee. FHA charges 1.75% upfront MIP and, for most buyers, 0.55% annual MIP.
Start with the map and the household income. If the home sits in a USDA-eligible area and your household income fits under the cap, USDA's zero down and lower annual fee usually make it the cheaper loan, and it is not close on cash to close.
If either test fails, FHA is the workhorse: any location, any income, more forgiving credit, and seller credits up to 6% to help with closing costs. FHA also moves at a normal lender pace, while USDA loans pass through a USDA review step that can add time.
Plenty of buyers qualify for both and still choose FHA for the faster, more predictable closing, or USDA for the lower monthly cost. Ryan and Steve run both structures on your actual home and income so the trade-off is in dollars, not guesses.
Processing differs too. An FHA loan is approved entirely by your lender, so the timeline is the lender's timeline. A USDA loan adds a second step: after the lender approves the file, USDA's own office reviews it before the final commitment, which can add days or weeks depending on volume. On a purchase with a firm closing date, that extra step is worth planning around, and on a short contract it can be the deciding factor all by itself.
The side-by-side for a quick decision.
| Factor | FHA | USDA |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment | 3.5% | 0% |
| Income limit | None | 115% of area median |
| Eligible areas | Anywhere | Rural and suburban areas only |
| Upfront fee | 1.75% MIP | 1% guarantee fee |
| Annual fee | 0.55% for most buyers | 0.35% |
| Credit approach | 580 for minimum down | No set score; lender standards apply |
| Seller credits | Up to 6% | Up to 6% |
| Best for | Flexibility anywhere | Zero down outside the city |
Both loans are for a primary residence you will occupy. Neither is an investment property program.
Zero down buying in eligible Indiana areas.
Check whether the home's address qualifies.
The household income cap, explained by household size.
Every FHA guide in one place, from down payment and credit to refinance.
The 3.5% down rules, sources, and documentation.
2MG Daily
Recent articles from our blog comparing loan programs for Indiana buyers.
Sep 2, 2026 • 2MG Daily
Read article →
Sep 3, 2026 • 2MG Daily
Read article →
When you qualify for USDA, it is usually cheaper: zero down, a 1% upfront fee, and a 0.35% annual fee versus FHA's 1.75% upfront and 0.55% annual MIP for most buyers. Qualifying is the catch.
Parts of the area qualify and parts do not; the eligibility map follows population density. Many homes outside the city limits are eligible. We check the exact address for you.
Then FHA is your low-down option, since it has no income limit. Conventional 3% down is worth pricing too if your credit is strong.
Yes. Both programs allow the seller to contribute up to 6% of the price toward your closing costs, which is one reason both work well for low-cash buyers.
Give Ryan & Steve the address and your household income, and they will price FHA and USDA side by side in real dollars.